Thanks for the extension!
I have unlynched TC btw
Ended Dunsparce's Pathetic Excuse For A Mafia Game - Game Over! Town Wins!
- Thread starter Dunsparce
- Start date
I have unlynched TC btw
Andy is scum. Here, after Jeroth and I both claimed townie, he attacks TC even though TC is now confirmed from his perspective as a townie. He doesn't necessarily need to claim townie in this situation, as doing so as a townie would reveal the doctor to the scum, but as townie or scum he now should have known TC is the doctor. Lynching the doctor today is an auto-win for scum.
Yep.
Follow up with this
Where TC's believability is a concern, even though he goes to claim townie and acknowledge that he knows myself or Jeroth to be scum (thus from his perspective, acting TC is pointless AND he knew TC was the doctor).
Lynch Andy
Let's also not forget that these claims have played out a lot like last game. While Andy could have legitimately waited until last to claim as a townie, it is concerning that this is a repeat of his scum play last game.
Unlynch Andy
Still very sus of him and willing to lynch, but don't want to put him one away from hammer just in case we're dumb and Jeroth is scum.
Still very sus of him and willing to lynch, but don't want to put him one away from hammer just in case we're dumb and Jeroth is scum.
Trust me, if I wanted to hammer, I would have. This is a tricky situation since it's going to be a LYLO unless you protect the correct target. I'd rather make certain we're all on board the proper lynch.
I want to hear more from Andy, but I know we're on borrowed time. I'm suspicious of Andy and I know Firedemon is also building a heavy case around him. I just need to see what Andy posts, so I can glean from it.
That one lynch was TC's lynch on you. I can see why that'd be confusing.
Ahhh shit, sorry. Cheers.
I've actually been running on the assumption that you're the only one who hadn't claimed. I thought you only claimed alignment, which I've quoted below, and were being just a coy as I've been.
This ambiguity is almost as bad as TC's dunders. I'll point out this also kills the rest of your argument against me, based around the actions I should do based on knowledge i'd have if I was scum.
A repeat of last game would be me (smartly) keeping my fuckin head down instead of going straight against the current the second you guys both decided to unlynch. Despite that change I had a massive hunch on TC and wanted to go through with it. Him being doctor actually makes sense because to say he's been acting normally this game is a massive stretch, and it's no surprise it's him of all players who made me change my position based on that behaviour.
Speaking of what happened last game, causing drama on day one really set the tone for defeat on day 2. If Dunsparce was even slightly less aggressive he would have stood a far better chance at convincing you on day 2. I'm in his shoes now (potentially if I survive), and I wasn't going to make the same mistake (until my terrible scum hunting sense got the better of me).
I imagine this will be my last post for the day, sorry I couldn't post any earlier.
In case I haven't already,
No Lynch.
So, aside from the fact that in that very quote I had stated I was agreeing with the claiming, implying I was claiming, you went on to say this with no further clarification on my role claim.
Clearly you did in fact know I was claiming vanilla townie, not just pointlessly stating my alignment. Otherwise you couldn't have concluded that the scum is either myself or Jeroth.
Actually I could conclude that, because TC's story was pretty fuckin elaborate and pretty fuckin believable. I also had to jump to defending myself, because after taking out a risky limb to go and lynch TC, it blew up in my face and almost (and still might) get me lynched, which would be a disaster for the town. Considering i'm TC's number 1 suspect as well, he wouldn't know who to protect besides himself but if I die and he doesn't get the protect right it's gg for us.
So yeah, with a pretty safe, quick and easy assumption that you seem to be ignoring, yeah I could conclude either you or Jeroth are scum. Not a massive leap.
Might not get a chance to post again this day phase, so I'll Lynch Andy bringing the total to two. I'm confident enough in Andy being scum to risk relying on protect if we're wrong. But, only if Jeroth is too. So this works well enough.
The Senate (Jeroth) will decide your fate.
The Senate (Jeroth) will decide your fate.
The players have failed to reach a consensus by the end of the allotted time. The day concludes without a lynch.
Night One begins. Night One will end at approximately 1:30 am EST on Sunday. Since that's not possible for me, Night One will actually end when I wake up on that day, or when all possible actions have been sent in. Here's the timer anyway:
Night One Countdown
Night One begins. Night One will end at approximately 1:30 am EST on Sunday. Since that's not possible for me, Night One will actually end when I wake up on that day, or when all possible actions have been sent in. Here's the timer anyway:
Night One Countdown
Night One ends. Nobody died.
Day Two begins. The day ends at approximately 9:00 PM EST on Monday.
Day Two Countdown
There's four players left standing. Three votes to lynch. Deja vu.
Day Two begins. The day ends at approximately 9:00 PM EST on Monday.
Day Two Countdown
There's four players left standing. Three votes to lynch. Deja vu.
@Colonel Thunder - Who the hell did you protect last night?
lmao I protected myself. I didn't outright state that, but I thought it was pretty obvious.
Making dinner brb
Making dinner brb
Well, shit. Fair enough. I was hoping you targeted Andy or Firedemon to make it easy, but whatever. I should have lynched Andy earlier today, but I had work.
Lynch Andy.
We might as well go for it.
I think I made my case and Andy made his, and since TC blocked his own death this is basically the same position as we were at the end of day 1. I just don't buy the defense that my claim wasn't obviously a claim. I don't have any more to say on this topic unless someone speaks up.
Lynch Andy
Lynch Andy
Watching Scott Pilgrim with Blooky so kinda busy. Will make a quick post to Lynch Andy tho!
Andy: "I misinterpreted my role and thought I was just a vanilla townie, who targets players and can maybe save them!"
It was really unfortunate that we both posted roleclaims within 2 minutes of each other as well.
I gotta know, though!
Guys,
If my original strat worked and I said "I'm the doctor and I accidentally revealed that I can't self-protect, oh no!" would you have targeted me?
I was pretty sure that Andy would be the only one to kill me in that situation, since FD and Jeroth have too much experience with me at this point to think I'm not up to something stupid.
I gotta know, though!
Guys,
If my original strat worked and I said "I'm the doctor and I accidentally revealed that I can't self-protect, oh no!" would you have targeted me?
I was pretty sure that Andy would be the only one to kill me in that situation, since FD and Jeroth have too much experience with me at this point to think I'm not up to something stupid.