Ahh fuck, Stealthy posted that at ~9am for me, so didn't really have a chance to post, been super busy at work. I have been reading though and been super conflicted over the discussion, but only skimming. I've now done a far deeper read. I think i've come to a conclusion. One I should have come to like, wayyyy earlier. Full apologies to everybody. There's been some key nuggets dropped that I really can't believe i've missed. Not only do I think Tirin has been uncharacteristically easy on me today, (I've made some not great posts imo),
-Andy won't reveal his role (I get you there, buddy)
Tirin stated this the night Anatron claims to have tried to kill Tirin. I'm dense as fuck and have some reason to believe that Tirin is townie. Nobody has come forward as a role blocker, and it seems like the only way Tirin could have survived last night is if he is Coolpool.
I don't have as much to contribute as those with power roles, but I will say that the objectives of the Fuck Dunsparce party have been fulfilled ahead of schedule and I only have one chance to be any more helpful to the Town beyond that.
In absence of a counter claim, I choose to "believe" TC despite his unconventional Day I for an info role (lynching a hunch takes away the Cop's main claim to credibility). As such, my greatest suspicions are Bob, Andy, Jeroth, and Tirin.
Anatron claiming one shot Vig here. Has anybody quoted this? I feel pretty confidant believing that he's somewhat pro town now, it's a perfect, well intentioned hint. It would take some forward planning for Anatron to pull this if he was scum, not that he couldn't do that obviously, but more likely the bloke is being genuine.
Regardless of whether or not TC is townie or scum, Dunsparce is surely confirmed town. It's classic for scum to *guess* or *investigate* real townies, (though not without risk), or if TC is a townie, then his word is honest.
So that leaves TC, assuming Tirin is Coolpool, and that Coolpool is a townie. On the other hand, Stealthy is pretty creative. The Walrus role was really cool. There is a possibility that Coolpool is the last remaining scum. However, I think this is less likely, but it would be a great way to fuck me up as a player.
I don't like TC claiming to have an ability on a cycle, it makes more sense for him to have a variety of abilities, of which he's claimed none of. I haven't liked TC's behaviour all game until he helped get Bob killed, but upon reflection he didn't even join that lynch. Tirin has been normal to me, even starting to agree with Jeroth against me, until last night, where I think I saved him. He has yet to say anything against me since (Though clearly TC has been a louder player), and the sentence I quoted before adds to this change of behaviour, where he kind of paints me in a more positive light.
I think TC, in the spirit of the game, has tried to fuckin bamboozle us gents. I think he might be scum. And if he isn't, then I believe it is surely Tirin. This is a shift from my opinion at the start of the day, where I thought it was 100% either Anatron or Tirin.
I would like to wait for someone to claim Coolpool, since it's what a big part of this analysis relies on. However it's night time for me and the day will end my time tomorrow morning when I start work.
Lynch TC