Tomorrow is Wednesday, which is also the deadline. I hope you mean you're back before then.
I meant tomorrow as in Tuesday, as that post was from late at night before I had actually attempted the act known as sleep. So yes, I am back before the deadline. Yay, imprecise language.
Why bring up something you don't believe? Why speculate so much on something you don't stand behind or wish to have analyzed? Because if we cut that part of your post out, all you wrote is a defense on why you weren't the one to kill White.
I think the remainder of his post was meant to be an admission of "Yeah, I was okay with killing him if you want to think that means I tried to kill him", because his following post stated he didn't want to ignore it in the event someone tried to pull it on him. Even after my post disagreeing with the logic of that hypothetical attack, I would still agree to that being okay, because someone could conceivably still try to pull that. That said, the crazy theory is... I didn't attack the act of posting it very much, I think it was too convoluted and he was too open about his absolute minimal belief of it for him to actually have any ill intentions with it. That said, you do raise a good point of, why did you even post it? I can't see him meaning to mislead with that, which is why I didn't heavily attack him for it, but I can't see why he would bother with it? Even if it were to drum up discussion, feel that was unnecessary at the time he posted it.
I'm not really opposed to a Tag lynch, but I'm not really in favor of it. I'm neutral on this, as I really don't find him that suspicious or that innocent.
I agree that Tag wasn't being aggressive (in the sense than everything he said literally meant nothing). Although, I do not agree with playing any assumption game. The mafia has just as much reason to not be on a lynch as to be on it. Avoid suspicion vs kill faster. There's no reason to not look at everyone. Especially when they're talking yet not saying anything.
Fair enough, I do see how this is a valid trade off for the mafia that some might make. However, I also think that, if the mafia is less experienced or less cunning/thoughtful/what-have-you, they could very easily go for a quick kill, or believe they're being less suspicious. Though you are certainly right, we should look at everyone.
The way it is looking to me Jeroth is is attempting to be more leaning against Tag and Requiem, in my opinion both people whom have tended to the discussion well, even if say Tag's theories hold no weight, he is pulling out his gut feels at the time. I'd say he has at least done more than I have in that way. I feel the best option from this point would be to Lynch Jeroth. I'd like to FoS Firedemon also since his choice between me and Jeroth seem based on so little, when this isn't as much about the gut on day 2, even if gut feelings helped pull discussion along before those were even denounced by the person putting it out of their ass after the fact.
Also it is funny that I post without having much to say or go on like everybody else, then get jumped on for not posting anything much to say or following the zero leads we might've had going on.
I'm not entirely opposed to a Jeroth lynch, for the minor suspicion reasons given before, and for minor suspicion of actually giving Tag's theory some support, which I apparently missed when reading his post. I based my suspicion of you on very little, yes, I even admitted that, and admitted that I don't generally think that's an adequate thing to go off after day 1, but I did explain the difference in suspicion levels and say I was only putting forth that vote to make something happen. As for what and how much you were saying, some of the other quiet people had been posting bits of substance, you had posted less in quantity and less of substance, so you stand out more.
I don't like Tag's logic of, he insists there are two mafia therefore he must be one of them. That's pretty flimsy logic to be actually attacking him with. Little suspicious, perhaps just desperate.
Also, on Tag's suggestion of Jeroth being quick to lynch someone who wasn't the top of his list despite saying we're at mylo, we're not in a situation where we lose if we mislynch (Which is mylo, correct? This isn't a slightly different situation, right?). That's tomorrow, like Jeroth showed with the numbers. I presume he meant that the following day would be mylo, as he did actually show the numbers clearly indicating that today is not mylo. So, he's not lynching someone who isn't his prime suspect during mylo, because it isn't mylo.
As I've gone through this, I've raised my suspicion level of Tag from where it was at the beginning of this post.
We have about four hours left. For the sake of avoiding a no lynch and moving the game forward, I will hammer Tag if nothing significantly changes in that time. In the mean time,
unlynch Ibix in preparation.
