You guys suck.
*sigh*
Mmkay, here are my thoughts on everyone:
Shadow - Town, duh.
Coolpool - Feels like inexperienced town.
Easy - Gonna go with town. If he's mafia, then he fooled me and he's a fucking genius.
Tag Ross - Is playing mostly from his phone or something and hasn't participated much. I have no thoughts on him right now.
Ro and Tolvan: Okay, first of all, here's the thing about Ro3. Y'know how Ro3's playing right now? That's ... that's just Ro3. Not just in this game. Not just in mafia. That's just Ro3 in general. That's just how he functions as a person. Trust me, I play a lot of League with that furry motherfucker. This is just how Ro3 is. If Ro3 wasn't playing like this, then there'd be a problem. You guys are just going to have to believe me here. Secondly, Ro3 is not a dumb mafia player. He actually plays mafia a lot more than we do (on a different site, naturally). I don't think he'd be dumb enough to claim mason with his scumbuddy like Jeroth is suggesting, knowing that he would implicate Tolvan if he got lynched and flipped mafia. Honestly, if they were a scum team, a better idea would have been for Tolvan to refute the mason claim and lynch Ro3 to make himself look innocent, but I don't think Tolvan is experienced enough at this game to pull off a play like that, and Ro3 wasn't under heavy enough fire at the time of the roleclaim for that play to even be necessary. I just ... I can't see either of them as scum. If they are, then Ro3 is a genius and Tolvan is better at this game than I'm giving him credit for.
Req - Feels a little off to me. I remember that one game that we played as a scum team (and I'm sad that the game thread no longer exists because I can't go back and check), where he basically just sat around and made his usual, long-winded posts, but didn't really commit to anything or contribute to the discussion in terms of what direction the town should go like he normally does, then waited for the town to decide who they wanted to lynch and just followed along. He's sorta doing that this game, both last day phase, and now here with Ro3. That said, he seems to be busy with IRL shit, and he may not have the time and/or energy to invest himself in the game, but ... ehh, I don't know, shit feels weird. Just thought I'd write this down in case I die.
Andy - Speaking of that game I played with Req as a scum team, because Andy said another thing that reminds me of that game, when he was talking about the mafia being dumb for killing TC last night when the town was all but going to lynch him today. Well, Req and I did exactly that the whole game, where we purposely killed off all of the prime targets each night just to fuck with town and confuse the hell out of them (I remember we made LM really mad, it was hilarious). I know this is a bit of a weak argument, but ... I don't know, but the fact that Andy pointed that out just feels scummy to me. It's like he's saying "hey guys, wow, the mafia sure is dumb for killing somebody that was probably going to get killed, what ever will we do now? **le trick face**" That said, I also acknowledge the strong possibility that he could be an innocent townie who happened to be in the wrong place at the wrong time and just said what was fairly obvious. I'll be honest, I'm not really sure what to think of Andy yet, partly because he hasn't said much, and partly because I'm still not entirely sure how I feel about Req.
Jeroth - Lynched Ro3 because he felt that Ro3 was acting scummy (and then a bunch of numbers and crap). He's basically saying "hey guys, look at that guy jumping around and waving his arms in the air, he's acting weird, let's lynch him" and trying to push the town towards the rather obvious kill. The only problem is that the way Ro3 is playing is how he normally plays, so when you look at this from my perspective, as a person who knows Ro3 is in general, this looks rather scummy. It looks like Jeroth is trying to use what Ro3 said and manufacture an argument against him, which is, like, exactly what scum does. And by all other accounts, Jeroth would probably have a legitimate case, but in this instance, I don't like it. Now, I completely understand that Ro3 could actually be scum and is banking on me blindly trusting him, but like I said earlier, Ro3 is either town, or he's a genius.
...
TL;DR - I believe Ro3 and Tolvan. Currently, I'm assuming a Jeroth/Req scum team, with either Andy or Tag Ross as the possible third scum.
