That would be pretty dumb of me to claim that I just RNG killed someone after already having proven myself to be the Gossip.
Pretty much sure Rondait was doctor anyways because of what he sent when Whitetiger Truth Serum'd him. Jeroth I'm pretty sure is town because of the Tirin Finally Played to His Win Condition Theorem, and Jeroth claims that Salsy is town because investigation. Not sure why Lotus would bother supporting that claim if he were Illuminati and Salsy were Mafia, and Lotus being Jeroth's "benefactor" he mentioned previously makes complete sense in this situation. Ro or Pally, I don't remember which, accidentally implied my alignment with the Gossip reveal (even though "Gossip" is a pretty stupid name for an anti-town role anyways, and my publish ability is pretty stupid to give to an anti-town role). Shizno was actually confirmed town by his reveal, and...
Wait, what if Salsy is the classic godfather role. As in, he flips town on investigations. Think about it, Tirin gunned for him pretty hard and was clearly under the impression scum hunting was an okay thing to do as Illuminati (which we know because Pally or Ro said it was funny that someone asked if the OP was accurate about win conditions after I pointed it out, then Tirin posted saying he just wanted to be sure) and it would explain why Jeroth and Lotus think he's Town even though we know from Tag (may he RIP in Peace) that Jeroth definitely wasn't redirected. And Salsy seems to have gotten really quiet since he was basically proven town, which would suggest maybe he's mafia thinking he seriously lucked out and just needs to shut the hell up until he wins. And he did side with Youma on the roleclaiming thing*. Though Tirin, before learning he was a fucking idiot for helping lynch Youma, was quick to pounce on my suggestion that the Illuminati might jump to Salsy's aid if he were the last mafia. This could have just been Tirin trying to consistently attack things he thought were dumb. I'm gonna leave Salsy floating around on my list of potentially mafia.
*Do note, the role claiming here is basically only working out because almost all of it is investigative information that can and has been corroborated/verified/whathaveyou. There was no reason to think the game would work this way at the beginning. We can have this theorycrafting argument later though.
Whitetiger is probably town because, while truth serum does sound a little anti-town-ish, I see no reason for an anti-town player to be able to publish information to the town. Maybe it was meant to be for Illuminati hunting by the mafia, but that just seems entirely too specialized.
Tim's claim can't be corroborated in any way, which doesn't necessarily make him anti-town. But, we can speculate that the last mafia would try to say something with some substance. Though we can also speculate that claiming a single use bulletproof is actually the perfect claim because it has no impact on anyone else. Therefore WIFOM and god dammit.
That leaves Andy and Polly. Andy has definitely been trolling me about anthropogenic climate change and can go suck Donald Trump's tiny, tiny dick. Only the mafia would deny climate change. But, since I whispered him a ten hour loop of the trolololol song last night, I think I can forgive him.
Polly's attempts to say my ability is "scummy as fuck" really rubbed me the wrong way. And not for OMGUS reasons, but because it's utter bullshit. At worst I'd be Illuminati, which town really has very little reason to bother lynching once identified, since the mafia will have to kill them anyways. But even then, sharing information with the town really isn't something an anti-town group like the Illuminati would do, especially when you consider the flavor. So assuming that Ro and Pally assigned abilities to alignments that would actually benefit from them, Polly made an absolutely atrocious argument in my mind. Of course, mistakes do not equate to being Mafia.
By the way, side note, lynching Illuminati that we know are Illuminati is actually pointless. The Mafia has to kill them to win but we don't, so we shouldn't waste a lynch on the Illuminati and save the Mafia the trouble of night killing them. Every known Illuminati we lynch is one more night kill the Mafia will use on a townie instead. And every known Illuminati we lynch is a potential chance at killing a Mafia we've thrown away. They might not do it immediately, but they have to do it or they will lose. We'll lose too, but assuming the last Mafia isn't a spiteful bastard that always wins the game of Chicken (do note that Tirin is dead and not Mafia), the Mafia will give in and take care of it for us.
Really not sure what to actually say about Andy, I'll have to come back to this subject.
