alright, I reread day 1 and came up with nothing.
Anny felt fishy, but I don't think he would have tried so hard to save his scum buddy. Especially when he had the chance to save him by adding his Lynch to Tim, if he was mafia the only other thing that probably would have happened is that shizno would have removed his zapy Lynch so we could get a kill, but that would have been so much better for scum.
As for Tim not giving reason to his Lynch, does my "just because" really beat something that had nothing attached? When I read it I thought the same thing I think for almost all day one lynches, it's a day one Lynch.
Shizno... hopping around was kind of odd. I've got my eyes on you, but I don't necessarily think you're scummy.
That leaves ciffy, tiger, and ice, I've got nothing, they didn't do much, ciffy and tiger retaliation lynched, ice day one lynched, that's all they did. If I had to pick anyone right now it would probably be one of them.